Alum Treatment at Teedyuskung Lake a Success

by Rebecca Buerkett, Project Scientist


F. X. Browne, Inc. conducted a phosphorus inactivation project at Teedyuskung Lake in Pike County, PA in November 2007. The 2008 post-treatment monitoring results indicate that the alum treatment significantly reduced the phosphorous and algae in Teedyuskung Lake. 

 

Teedyuskung Lake has been eutrophic for the past 17+ years, as evidenced by high nutrient concentrations, high chlorophyll a concentrations, high algal counts and densities, domination by bluegreen algae (cyanobacteria), hypolimnetic oxygen depletion, and decreased water transparency. Low dissolved oxygen conditions at the bottom of the lake were causing phosphorus to be released from the sediments, subsequently fueling algae growth. A batch alum treatment was performed on Teedyuskung Lake to seal the bottom, phosphorus-rich sediments and prevent phosphorus resuspension in the water column.

F. X. Browne, Inc. performed an in-depth study of Teedyuskung Lake which included water sampling, alum and sodium aluminate jar tests, sediment testing for phosphorus content, a bathymetric survey of the lake, and calculations of the doses of alum and sodium aluminate required. The jar tests were performed to measure the dose required to treat the water column of the lake. Additional jar tests were performed to determine the combination of alum and sodium aluminate required to maintain a pH of 6 or greater.

A dose of aluminum of 13 mg/l was added to the 80 acre lake by applying 33,000 gallons of alum and 16,000 gallons of sodium aluminate to the lake. This dose was in the mid-range of alum doses used on lakes throughout the country.

F. X. Browne, Inc. conducted pre- and post- alum treatment water quality monitoring at Teedyuskung Lake in 2007 and 2008 in order to document the success of the treatment. The monitoring results showed a dramatic improvement in surface water quality after treatment in 2007 and continuing through the 2008 growing season, as shown in Table 1. In particular, the total phosphorus and chlorophyll a concentrations and Secchi disk readings improved from the eutrophic range pre-treatment to the oligotrophic or borderline oligotrophic-mesotrophic range post-treatment. The 2008 bottom water quality total phosphorus average was much improved over the 2007 pre-treatment average hypolimnetic total phosphorus average.

The phytoplankton (algae) populations dropped dramatically post-treatment. Additional monitoring during future field seasons will determine whether or not these water quality improvements will be long-lasting, but that is expected to be the case.

Table 1

Water Quality Results Before and After Alum Treatment in Teedyuskung Lake

Parameter

Surface Waters

Bottom Waters

2007 Average

Post-Treatment

2008 Average

2007 Average

Post-Treatment

2008 Average

Total Phosphorus (mg/L)

0.024

0.009

0.008

0.452

0.008

0.044

Chlorophyll a (µg/L)

30.9

0.9

3.4

*

*

*

Total Suspended Solids (mg/L)

4.9

<1.0

2.1

9.1

1.2

5.1

Transparency (m)

2.0

4.5

4.4

*

*

*

* Surface parameter only